Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Billy Crystal's Crisis Of Faith

In an interview with “CBS Sunday Morning,” correspondent Tracy Smith asked Billy Crystal if he has been talking to God over the last two years, given the amount of grief and pain he’s endured.

“No, ‘cause I don’t trust Him,” Crystal replied. “Too many bad things have happened. The Earth is in bad shape. This is a weird, scary time, so no. Not anymore.” 

Crystal’s Pacific Palisades home burned down in the Los Angeles wildfires, a place he described as “magical” and central to his family life. 

He also cited the murder of Rob Reiner. Reiner and his wife Michele, an event Crystal said was “too big” and “insane” to process. 

So first - Hakaras Hatov!! Billy has made me laugh many times. THANKS BILLY!!! 

Now to his abandonment of G-d. 

Billy is a comedian - not a theologian or philosopher. I would guess he spends little time reading books on deeper topics. I would guess that he hasn't been through Tanach - particularly Sefer Iyov that deals with the question of theodicy. I would also bet more than a few dollars that he, a Jew, hasn't read the great works of Jewish philosophy that deal with the question of human suffering. 

I would also ask him - what happened?? You believed in G-d after the Holocaust. Six million of your people, starved, tortured and then gassed - including one and a half million pure children. After that you could still talk to G-d. 

You believed in G-d after the Spanish Inquisition where among other pleasures - they administered garrucha, toca, and potro. The garrucha (or strappado) involved suspending victims by their wrists, tied behind their back, sometimes with weights on their feet, causing violent pulls and dislocations during lifts and drops. 

La Toca (Water Torture): An early form of waterboarding. The prisoner was bound and immobilized, and a strip of linen or silk cloth (the toca) was placed over their face or pushed down into their mouth and throat. Interrogators would then slowly pour water from jars onto the cloth. As the fabric soaked up the water, it blocked the airway and forced the victim to swallow water while suffocating, inducing an intense panic and sensation of drowning. Interrogators paused between jars to give the prisoner a chance to confess.   

El Potro (The Rack): A wooden frame—named after the Spanish word for a colt or young horse—fitted with ropes and windlasses (rollers). The prisoner was laid on the frame with their wrists and ankles tied to the ropes. As the interrogator turned the levers, the ropes pulled the victim's limbs in opposite directions, severely stretching the muscles and joints and often causing agonizing dislocations. (In many instances, la toca was administered while the prisoner was already tied down to el potro.) So after that you were still OK with G-d. 

And what about little children with horrible illnesses? You never heard of that??!! 

But your mansion burns down and so you decide G-d can't be trusted. Or your friend is killed not by G-d but by his crazy son and you're done??!!!

How does that make sense? The answer is that it doesn't. It is purely an emotional reaction by someone who never had a real relationship with, or understanding of, G-d, to start with.   

So here is THE answer!! G-d exists because [among other things] there is no other plausible explanation for everything that exists other than G-d. Period. Full stop. Nothing doesn't create everything. Sorry Dawkins. [Actually, I'm not sorry].

Do we understand all the details? No. Do we have to understand all the details to believe in G-d and have a relationship with him? Of course not. Does G-d have to conform to OUR standards? That would be SILLY! Then he wouldn't be G-d - he would just be a pathetic human being. A "broken shard, withering grass, fading flower, passing shadow, dissipating cloud, blowing wind, floating dust, and a fleeting dream." A putrid drop of .... Really Billy - we want G-d to be bigger than we are. I wouldn't want to believe [echoing the Kotzker] in a G-d who is so small that I understand everything he does, given my very very very very limited and narrow view of reality.  

So Billy - if you are reading this, I offer you a chavrusa and we can start learning about G-d and give our life some meaning beyond making people laugh. 

And remember: 

"When man abandons G-d, G-d is not alone. Man is". 

"When a man stops believing in God he doesn’t then believe in nothing, he believes anything."


Three Whose Names Preceded Their Existence—Those Bound to the Essence of the Beis HaMikdash

What Does It Mean That They Were Called by Name Before They Were Created?

Let us continue exploring the subject we began last week—the inner significance of Yishmael.

Chazal state in Bereishis Rabbah (45:8):

"Rebbi Yitzchak said: Three individuals were called by their names before Hakadosh Baruch Hu prior to their creation, and they are: Yitzchak, Shlomo, and Yoshiyahu. Regarding Yitzchak it is written: 'Aval Sarah ishtecha yoledes lecha ben v’karasa es shemo Yitzchak' (Bereishis 17:19). Regarding Shlomo, what does it state? 'Hinei ben nolad lecha hu yihyeh ish menuchah... Shlomo yihyeh shemo' (Divrei HaYamim I 22:9). Regarding Yoshiyahu it is written: 'Vayikra el hamizbei’ach bidvar Hashem vayomar mizbei’ach mizbei’ach koh amar Hashem, hinei ben nolad l’Beis Dovid Yoshiyahu shemo' (Melachim I 13:2). And some say (v’yeish omrim): even Yishmael among the nations, as it is written: 'Hinach harah v’yoladt ben v’karasa es shemo Yishmael' (Bereishis 16:11)."

There were three individuals whose names were fixed prior to their birth—their shem preceded their creation, their coming into being, their very existence. They were born into a name predetermined for them from above. Both the inner essence of these three figures and the broader concept of a person’s name preceding his existence require deep elucidation.

Indeed, the dispute regarding whether Yishmael is included in this list appears astonishing at first glance. The Mefarshim already raise the obvious question: is it not explicitly written in the pasuk that Yishmael was named prior to his birth? Clearly, then, the debate is not over whether it occurred factually, but rather whether the fact that Yishmael was named before birth places him in the same category—whether it stems from the exact same spiritual root as these three individuals or not. According to the Yeish Omrim, there is a list of four figures whose connection to one another appears utterly remote and foreign, yet their common denominator is precisely this: they were called by name before Hakadosh Baruch Hu prior to their birth. Let us attempt to understand, according to our limited grasp, what it means to be called by name before being born, and how Yishmael relates to this.

(This week we will elucidate the three—Yitzchak, Shlomo, and Yoshiyahu—and b’ezras Hashem, based on this foundation, next week we will clarify the matter of Yishmael.)

A Na’eh World Is a World Aligned with the Revelation of Its Name

The shem (name) of any entity represents its transcendent essence—an inner reality standing above the immediate framework of here and now, of Olam HaZeh, within which the entity lives and operates. A thing’s shem is its primordial essence (mahuso ha’rishonah), which, ordinarily, upon emerging into physical actualization (yetzi’ah l’fo’al), it fails to fulfill completely. Typically, there is a disconnect between an entity’s actualized existence in this world and its shem and inner essence.

It follows clearly that when a creation comes into being and—even after its creation—remains bound to the transcendental root from which it emerged, such that its physical actualization contains nothing other than the pure fulfillment of the Divine intent for which it was brought forth, that is what it means for a creation to be called by its shem before it was born. That is, in its tangible existence and actualization, there is nothing extraneous—solely the unfolding of that predetermined shem.

Once during the history of Creation—prior to the sin of Adam HaRishon—the entire world stood in complete alignment with its shem. As Chazal relate in Koheles Rabbah (7:13):

"When Hakadosh Baruch Hu created Adam HaRishon, He took him and led him around all the trees of Gan Eden and said to him: 'See My works, how pleasant (na’im) and praiseworthy they are; everything I created, I created for you. Set your mind that you do not corrupt and destroy My world.'"

The precise definition of the word na’eh is that an entity befits its name and its name befits it (na’eh l’shmo u’shmo na’eh lo). We see this explicitly in the Gemara in Nedarim (66b) regarding a husband who vowed not to derive benefit from his wife unless she could show him one na’eh quality about herself. She could find none and came before Rebbi Yishmael bar Rebbi Yossi. He inquired into every physical trait and indeed found nothing attractive—until he asked her name. She replied, "Lichluchis (Filthy) is my name." Rebbi Yishmael declared: "Yafeh korin osah Lichluchis shehi meluchleches b’mumin"—fittingly is she called Lichluchis, for she is covered in blemishes!—and he permitted her to her husband. He told her: This is the na’eh quality within you—your name befits you and you befit your name!

Thus, the essence of something being na’eh is its complete correspondence to its shem. When Hakadosh Baruch Hu led Adam through the newly created universe and declared, "See how na’eh My world is," ultimate beauty meant that Creation was wholly aligned with its shem. "Set your mind that you do not corrupt and destroy My world" meant: do not sever Creation from its bond to its shem; do not render it unworthy of its name; do not ruin the harmony between a thing’s shem and its actualized existence.

The Erection of the Mishkan: "Ka’asher Tzivah Hashem Es Moshe"

There was one subsequent moment in history when something analogous occurred—when Creation was brought forth in a second edition. This took place at the erection of the Mishkan, which corresponded completely to Ma’aseh Bereishis. As Chazal state in Berachos (55a): "Rav Yehudah said in the name of Rav: Betzalel knew how to permute the letters with which heaven and earth were created." Chazal teach that the Mishkan was a complete recapitulation of the creation of the universe; nothing exists in the cosmos without its counterpart in the Mishkan, and no structural relationship exists in Creation without its parallel in the Mishkan.

Regarding the assembly of the Mishkan, the Torah devotes an entire parashah whose singular refrain is that every single element was executed "כַּאֲשֶׁר צִוָּה ה' אֶת מֹשֶׁה"—as Hashem commanded Moshe. The Torah recounts that they erected this component, this vessel, and this vestment, and every single item was fashioned ka’asher tzivah Hashem es Moshe. That is, the physical actualization matched the Divine blueprint with absolute precision. Within "ka’asher tzivah Hashem es Moshe" lay the shem of each item, and its physical assembly was its actualization—and the Torah testifies that in the Mishkan, every physical realization corresponded completely to the Divine command. Those were the rare junctures in history when total alignment existed between a thing’s shem and its tangible reality.

The Beis HaMikdash Is the Locus Where Heaven and Earth Unite

Ever since the world became corrupted, blemished, and diminished, this harmony no longer exists across the globe. There remains one single place where that bond persists between an entity’s primordial, innermost shem and its tangible existence below: the Beis HaMikdash.

This is the sole locus of avodah, the place where the terrestrial realm below aligns directly opposite the celestial realm above—where "sulam mutzav artzah v’rosho magi’a hashamaymah, v’malachei Elokim olim v’yordim bo." Here one can ascend from earthly reality to heavenly reality, and descend from heavenly reality into earthly reality; here exists correspondence between both realms. Wherever we find a mutual joining of shamayim and aretz, there we find—either in full or at least in part—harmony between a thing’s existence and its shem. In the Beis HaMikdash, the correspondence is total: the Beis HaMikdash shel matah is aligned directly opposite the Beis HaMikdash shel ma’alah, zeh k’neged zeh.

The Gemara in Kesubos (5a) states:

"Bar Kappara expounded: Greater are the deeds of the tzaddikim than the creation of heaven and earth! For regarding the creation of heaven and earth it is written: 'Af yadi yasdah eretz vi’mini tipchah shamayim' (Yeshayahu 48:13)—using one hand each; whereas regarding the handiwork of the tzaddikim [the Beis HaMikdash] it is written: 'Machon l’shivtecha pa’alta Hashem, Mikdash Hashem konanu yadecha' (Shemos 15:17)—with both hands together!"

In Ma’aseh Bereishis, as it were, the Creator fashioned earth separately with His "left hand" ("yadi yasdah eretz") and heaven separately with His "right hand" ("vi’mini tipchah shamayim"). In the construction of the Beis HaMikdash, however, both hands acted in unison—right and left converged. That is, heaven and earth meet there as one; it is the nexus where the supernal realms fuse with the entire lower order.

Yitzchak Was the First to Open the Gate Above

That Beis HaMikdash was founded by Yitzchak and built by Shlomo.

Yitzchak was the first korban in the world. Concerning Yitzchak at the Akeidah, the Torah states: "Vayikra Avraham shem hamakom hahu Hashem Yir’eh, asher yei’ameir hayom b’Har Hashem yeira’eh" (Bereishis 22:14). Through Akeidas Yitzchak, that site was consecrated as an eternal locus of avodah for all generations. Thus, Yitzchak is the rishon—the primordial root of avodah, of Mikdash, and of korban in the world. (Even though Adam, Noach, and Avraham himself had previously offered korbanos, the permanent sanctity of the Makom HaMikdash was not established through those offerings.) Every Jew who ascends l’regel ascends to the site of Akeidas Yitzchak. Yitzchak established the sanctity of the Beis HaMikdash; he was the first to breach open the gateway between heaven and earth.

Chazal state in Devarim Rabbah (11:3): "Vayehi ki zakein Yitzchak vatich’hena einav mei’ros—what is 'mei'ros'? From gazing upon the Shechinah!" Why did Yitzchak grow blind? Because at the moment of the Akeidah, the heavens split open and he beheld what no mortal can behold; and as Rashi cites, when he lay bound upon the mizbei’ach as his father prepared to slaughter him, the heavens opened, the Malachei HaShareis wept, and their tears fell into his eyes, blinding him. Anyone with ears to hear the words of Chazal understands from this that at Akeidas Yitzchak, the heavenly portal was unlocked.

From that moment onward, the sanctity of the site remained latent until Shlomo came and built the Bayis: "Asher yei’ameir hayom b’Har Hashem yeira’eh." Shlomo actualized the sanctity of the site in its most complete manifestation—the Beis HaMikdash, whose kedushah is eternal ("l’olam ein haShechinah zazah misham"), "Zeh makom Beis Hashem Elokim v’zeh mizbei’ach l’olah l’Yisrael" (Divrei HaYamim I 22:1), "Poh eisheiv ki ivisiha" (Tehillim 132:14). That was what Shlomo constructed.

The Prophecy That Yoshiyahu Would Be Born—and That Such Would Be His Name

Now let us understand the role of Yoshiyahu.

At the opening of Melachim I Chapter 13, the navi recounts:

"V’hinei ish Elokim ba mi’Yehudah bidvar Hashem el Beis-El, v’Yarov’am omeid al hamizbei’ach l’haktir. Vayikra al hamizbei’ach bidvar Hashem vayomar: Mizbei’ach, mizbei’ach, koh amar Hashem: Hinei ben nolad l’Beis Dovid, Yoshiyahu shemo, v’zavach alecha es kohanei habamos hamaktirim alecha v’atzmos adam yisrefu alecha."

Standing before the idolatrous altar erected by Yarov’am ben Nevat, the ish Elokim prophesied concerning an event many generations into the future—for numerous generations separated Yarov’am from Yoshiyahu—declaring by name: "Yoshiyahu shemo!"

Yoshiyahu, son of Amon, son of Menasheh, ascended the throne at eight years old (Melachim II 22:1), and Scripture testifies: "Vaya’as hayashar b’einei Hashem vayelech b’chol derech Dovid aviv v’lo sar yamin u’semol." Let us examine the specific episode in the navi that illuminates our theme.

Chuldah Sent Word to Yoshiyahu That for Him, There Would Be No Churban

Later in that chapter, King Yoshiyahu sends a delegation—Chilkiyahu HaKohen, Achikam, Achbor, Shafan, and Asayah—to Chuldah HaNeviah to inquire of Hashem after discovering the Sefer Torah in the Beis HaMikdash. Chuldah responds with a grim prophecy concerning the impending destruction of Yerushalayim:

"Koh amar Hashem: Hineni meivi ra’ah el hamakom hazeh v’al yoshvav... v’nitzsah chamasi bamakom hazeh v’lo sichbeh."

Immediately afterward, however, Chuldah adds a specific message addressed personally to the King:

"V’el Melech Yehudah hasholei’ach eschem lidrosh es Hashem, koh somru eilav... Ya’an rach levavcha vatikan’a mipnei Hashem b’shom’acha asher dibarti al hamakom hazeh v’al yoshvav lihyot l’shammah v’liklalah, vatikra es begadecha vativkeh l’fanai, v’gam Anochi shamati ne’um Hashem. Lachein hineni osifcha al avosecha v’ne’esafta el kivrosecha b’shalom, v’lo sir’ena einecha b’chol hara’ah asher Ani meivi al hamakom hazeh." (Melachim II 22:18–20)

Chuldah’s prophecy informs Yoshiyahu that a decree of curse and destruction has been sealed upon Yerushalayim. By right, Yoshiyahu himself ought to have been swept up in that decree; yet because his heart softened and he humbled himself before Hashem, the decree was nullified regarding him—he was exempted from it.

Now, if we understand this deeply: when Hashem tells Yoshiyahu, "Your eyes shall not see all the evil that I am bringing upon this place," the intent is not merely that he will pass away beforehand so as not to witness the tragedy visually—for if that were all, would knowing it was inevitable not already grieve him? Rather, the deeper meaning is that with respect to Yoshiyahu, it is as though this prophecy of Churban was never decreed! He is removed entirely from the jurisdiction of the decree. With regard to Yoshiyahu, Yerushalayim was never destroyed at all! Let us now explain that this was no arbitrary personal favor, but was bound up with the very essence of Yoshiyahu’s mission.

Yoshiyahu Concealed the Aron So That It Would Never Go into Exile

Chazal expound in Yoma (52b) that Yoshiyahu hid away (ganaz) the Aron HaKodesh so that it would not be carried into exile. The Rambam codifies this in Hilchos Beis HaBechirah (4:1):

"There was a stone in the western part of the Kodesh HaKodashim upon which the Aron rested, and before it stood the jar of Mannah and the staff of Aharon. When Shlomo built the Bayis, knowing that it was destined to be destroyed, he constructed within it a chamber beneath the ground in deep, labyrinthine vaults in which to conceal the Aron. And King Yoshiyahu commanded that it be hidden in that place which Shlomo had built, as it is stated: 'Vayomer laLevi’im hamevinim l’chol Yisrael hakedoshim laHashem: Tenu es Aron HaKodesh baBayis asher banah Shlomo ben Dovid Melech Yisrael, ein lachem masa bakaseif...' (Divrei HaYamim II 35:3). And together with it were concealed the staff of Aharon, the jar of Mannah, and the anointing oil—none of which returned in the Second Temple."

The Radak (ibid.) and Rashi explain similarly that Yoshiyahu hid the Aron beneath that stone—which served as the cover to the subterranean labyrinth built by Shlomo—so that it would never be exiled among the captives, and so that from there it could one day be uncovered anew.

Notice the wording of the pasuk: "Tenu es Aron HaKodesh baBayis asher banah Shlomo ben Dovid Melech Yisrael." Even those deep subterranean vaults beneath the earth are explicitly designated by Scripture as part of "the House which Shlomo built." Yoshiyahu placed the Aron inside those hidden depths—which are still part of Beis Shlomo—so it would never suffer exile.

The Root of Hashra’as HaShechinah Resides in the Aron—And Through Genizah, the Aron Remains With Us

It is a foundational truth that the entire sanctity of the Makom HaMikdash—indeed, the entire root of kedushah and Hashra’as HaShechinah within Klal Yisrael—resides in and upon the Aron. From there the Shechinah was revealed; from there Torah was given—from above the Kappores, between the two Keruvim. Everything encompassed by "V’asu Li Mikdash v’shachanti b’socham" (Shemos 25:8) is realized through the Aron. When the Aron stood openly in the Beis HaMikdash, Hashra’as HaShechinah was overt, manifest, and unobstructed.

However, from the moment Yoshiyahu concealed the Aron, Hashra’as HaShechinah within Klal Yisrael continues b’ma’amakim, b’genizah—in hidden depths! It is as though that very Beis HaMikdash which Shlomo erected above ground descended intact into the subterranean vaults beneath the earth. Down there, it is still called Beis Hashem—"the House which Shlomo built." And inside that hidden House, the Aron is still sitting right there!

True, we cannot physically access that chamber; it is sealed and locked away in the subterranean vaults until the Creator wills to raise it up and reveal His Shechinah before all eyes. Yet until that day, the Aron—which bears within itself the totality of Kedushas HaMikdash and Hashra’as HaShechinah—remains preserved inside the House in genizah. On the surface it is invisible, requiring profound spiritual depth to perceive; yet in those hidden depths, it exists just as intact as when it stood openly above ground!

(As Chazal make clear, when the Aron was hidden away, the Kappores and the two Keruvim formed of a single piece with it were hidden away alongside it. There is no contradiction from Reish Lakish's statement in Yoma 54b that when the invaders entered the Heichal during the Churban they saw the Keruvim intertwined—for as Melachim I 6:23 explicitly records, there were two sets of Keruvim in the Kodesh HaKodashim: the two golden Keruvim beaten out of the Kappores itself, and two giant olive-wood Keruvim standing on the floor on either side of the Aron, spreading their wings over it from above. Yoshiyahu concealed the Aron together with its Kappores and attached Keruvim long before the Churban; the Keruvim found at the Churban were the outer standing pair.)

From between those two Keruvim atop the Kappores, Hashem spoke to Moshe; from between them Torah was given. That represents the very essence of Torah—Hashem’s speech to us, His intimate bond with us, our togetherness with the Borei Olam. All of that resides in the Aron.

Had the Aron ever been carried off into exile, chas v’shalom, that would have been a catastrophic blow—as though Hashra’as HaShechinah within Israel had been compromised, chas v’shalom, as though impure hands had laid hold of the true bond between Hashem and His people, leaving no hope of restoration. By concealing the Aron, Yoshiyahu ensured that the very reality which existed openly in the days of Shlomo continues to exist uninterruptedly in genizah.

Yoshiyahu Built the Beis HaMikdash That Endures With Us in Genizah—For Him, There Is No Churban

Thus, Shlomo’s Beis HaMikdash was constructed twice:

  1. Once openly above ground—built by Shlomo;

  2. And a second time in concealment, within the subterranean vaults—built by Yoshiyahu!

What Shlomo constructed was the Bayis in overt revelation (b’gilui); what Yoshiyahu constructed was that exact same Bayis in concealment (b’genizah). In the Bayis Rishon, "V’shachanti b’socham" operated overtly; since Yoshiyahu’s act, "V’shachanti b’socham" operates in the hidden depths—in vaults where no foreign eye can ever gain dominion, and where even our own eyes can penetrate only with immense effort. Though usually hidden even from ourselves, it exists—for were it not truly existing down there, chas v’shalom, we too could not survive in exile.

Concerning Yoshiyahu, Scripture testifies: "V’chamohu lo hayah l’fanav melech asher shav el Hashem b’chol levavo u’v’chol nafsho u’v’chol me’odo k’chol Toras Moshe, v’acharav lo kam kamohu" (Melachim II 23:25). No king before or after him ever returned to Hashem with such totality of heart, soul, and might. Therefore, he merited to construct an indestructible dimension of the Bayis that accompanies us throughout the entire duration of hester panim. Within that genizah, Yoshiyahu preserved the entire sanctity of Beis Shlomo—and by virtue of that hidden genizah, we endure.

Shlomo built a House that was destroyed; Yoshiyahu built a House that was never destroyed and can never be destroyed. The indestructibility of Shlomo’s edifice was built by Yoshiyahu!

To one who reflects, everything becomes crystal clear: for Yoshiyahu, there was no decree of Churban! That is the profound truth behind Chuldah’s prophecy: "You shall not see this evil." For you, it does not exist—because you entered those hidden depths and deposited the Aron there! For one who dwells in those depths, the Churban simply does not exist; down in those vaults, everything remains intact as it always was.

Three Whose Inner Essence United Heaven and Earth

We have now understood Yitzchak, Shlomo, and Yoshiyahu—the three individuals whose shem preceded their physical existence. When they were born, their earthly lives fulfilled and actualized their predetermined shem—the innermost spiritual essence denoted by their names. They were born intrinsically bound to their shem; their names were not bestowed retroactively, rather the shem existed first, and their lives actualized it.

This is the very essence of uniting shamayim and aretz:

  • Shamayim is the realm of pure shem, as Yeshayahu (40:26) states: "Se’u marom eineichem u’re’u mi bara eileh, hamotzi b’mispar tzva’am l’chulam b’shem yikra"—in heaven, every creation actualizes its shem completely.

  • Aretz, by contrast, is the realm where the shem is concealed, where only physical, material actualization appears on the surface.

When the earthly actualization below aligns completely with the transcendent shem above, that creation is one whose shem was revealed prior to its birth and then brought into full actualization in this world.

Why Bayis Sheini Is Not Included—And the Mystery of "V’Yeish Omrim Af Yishmael"

All three figures enumerated here are bound to the building of the Beis HaMikdash. Clearly, the construction of the Bayis Sheini does not belong here: Bayis Sheini was not a new spiritual creation, but a lesser physical replica lacking the Aron and the five foundational elements. As the Ramchal reveals in Mishkenei Elyon—an astonishing chiddush found nowhere else—Bayis Sheini had no celestial counterpart (Beis HaMikdash shel ma’alah) corresponding to it: during Bayis Rishon, the Beis HaMikdash shel ma’alah aligned with it; and the moment Bayis Sheini was built, the celestial counterpart above was already that of the Bayis HaShlishi!

We have thus elucidated the first half of Chazal’s statement: Yitzchak, Shlomo, and Yoshiyahu are the three builders of the bond between heaven and earth. Yitzchak laid the primordial foundation at the Akeidah; Shlomo built the Bayis in overt revelation; and Yoshiyahu built the eternal dimension of the Bayis in genizah. All three were born as pure actualizations of their pre-existing shem.

Now, however, Chazal confront us with a staggering addition: "וְיֵשׁ אוֹמְרִים אַף יִשְׁמָעֵאל"—And some say: even Yishmael!

Ostensibly, what is Yishmael doing on this list?! How does he enter the company of Yitzchak, Shlomo, and Yoshiyahu? And moreover, we must understand: from where did Yishmael receive the power granted to him to hold dominion over this very sacred site—the Makom HaMikdash—for such a vast stretch of history? (B’ezras Hashem, this we will uncover next week.)

Yaakov Avinu Reveals the Complete Form of Adam That Synthesizes All Forces

This Parashah is Filled with Stones from Beginning to End

"Vayeitzei Yaakov mi’Be’er Sheva vayelech Charanah" (Bereishis 28:10). In this parashah, Yaakov Avinu goes out to build the House of Israel (Beis Yisrael). That is evidently the reason why the entire parashah is filled with stones—it begins with stones and ends with stones.

At its outset: "Vayikach mei’avnei hamakom vayasem m’ra’ashosav" (ibid., 28:11). Immediately afterward: "Vayikach es ha’even asher sam m’ra’ashosav vayasem osah matzeivah" (ibid., 28:18). Later, Yaakov continues on his journey and sees a well in the field, "v’ha’even gedolah al pi habe’er" (ibid., 29:2). And the parashah concludes with: "Vayomer Yaakov l’echav liktu avanim vaya’asu gal" (ibid., 31:46). Almost every motif in this parashah revolves around stones—repeatedly, in myriad forms—because when Yaakov sets out to build a house, a house is constructed out of stones. A stone is always a foundation upon which to build, a foundation for continuity, a foundation for a home. Thus is Beis Yisrael constructed. Accordingly, on the pasuk "Mishom ro’eh Even Yisrael" (ibid., 49:24), Rashi writes: "Even is an acronym (notarikon) for Av Ben—avahan u’venin, Yaakov and his sons."

The Fused Stones and the Dream Converge into a Single Revelation

At the beginning of the narrative, the Torah states: "Vayifga bamakom vayalen sham ki va hashemesh, vayikach mei’avnei hamakom vayasem m’ra’ashosav." This is the starting point. Chazal teach (Chullin 91b, cited by Rashi here) that all the stones quarreled with one another, each stone declaring, "Upon me shall the tzaddik rest his head!" Ultimately, through this, all the stones merged together, fused into one single stone—and that stone became the Even HaShesiyah, the Foundation Stone upon which the entire world was established (see Pirkei D’Rebbi Eliezer ch. 35). It became the bedrock foundation of all creation, as the Gemara in Yoma (54b) says regarding the Even HaShesiyah: "Tanna: she’mimenah hushtas ha’olam"—from it the world was founded. This is the very stone concerning which Yaakov declared: "V’ha’even hazos asher samti matzeivah yihyeh Beis Elokim" (Bereishis 28:22)—upon this it is built.

We find an additional element here: "Vayishkav bamakom hahu"—followed by the dream in which Yaakov saw "sulam mutzav artzah v’rosho magi’a hashamaymah," and immediately afterward: "Vayikatz Yaakov mishnaso... vayira vayomar... ein zeh ki im Beis Elokim v’zeh sha’ar hashamayim" (ibid., 28:16–17).

Since two distinct phenomena are recorded here—both converging to reveal that this site is Beis Elokim and Sha’ar HaShamayim—it follows necessarily that the dream joins together with the fusion of the stones. Both elements converge into one: both testify to the exact same truth—the stone erected as a matzeivah that will become Beis Elokim, and the dream proclaiming, "Ein zeh ki im Beis Elokim."

We have two testimonies here, appearing on the surface as two distinct events, two separate occurrences, whose inner essence is one. Clearly, there must be a single unifying principle that binds, synthesizes, and fuses them into one unified testimony: here stands the stone fused out of all the individual stones, marking this site as Beis Elokim; and here occurred the dream, the vision of the ladder—and these two together demonstrate that this is Beis Elokim.

What Distinguished Yaakov Avinu to Be Called Bechir She’ba’Avos?

Yaakov Avinu was, in the language of Chazal (Bereishis Rabbah 76:1), "הבחיר שבאבות"—the choicest of the Patriarchs. Yaakov’s bed was completely unblemished (mitaso sheleimah), as the Gemara in Shabbos (146a) states:

"Rebbi Abba bar Kahana said: Until three generations, the spiritual impurity (zuhama) did not cease from our forefathers: Avraham fathered Yishmael; Yitzchak fathered Eisav; Yaakov fathered twelve tribes in whom there was no flaw whatsoever."

From Yaakov, no spiritual dross emerged. Yaakov is a complete human being—"ish tam"—utterly whole, without deficiency, blemish, or defect; a complete Adam.

We must deeply understand what distinguishes Yaakov in this regard. What makes him who he is? After all, the Gemara’s formulation indicates a distinct preeminence of Yaakov—which, evidently, is the very reason he is Bechir She’ba’Avos. Where lies this point of superiority of Yaakov over Avraham and Yitzchak, who were his own parents and from whose spiritual strength he emerged?

How Is It Possible to Choose Between Two Equally Balanced Sides?

There is a fundamental philosophical difficulty in understanding the faculty of bechirah (free choice). Let us clarify this, and through it, we will arrive at an understanding of Yaakov Avinu’s unique stature.

We know that the Borei Olam granted man the power of bechirah—the capacity to choose evil or to choose good. The Creator placed both sides before man as equally balanced (shekulim), and man is obligated to choose—and of course, he is commanded to choose good: "U’vacharta bachayim" (Devarim 30:19).

Yet for anyone who reflects deeply upon this, a massive difficulty arises: if the two sides stand before us in genuine equilibrium—where both options are truly equal in pull—from where does the power of decision (koach ha’hachra’ah) emerge? How is it possible for a human being to decide between two sides that are completely balanced? Two equally weighted sides inherently preclude a decisive tilt!

Our habitual way of conceptualizing a decision is to assume that if we look deeper, the two sides weren't actually equal—that every act of choice retroactively reveals there was never any real doubt. This is false. That is not the truth, and that is not what bechirah means. Free choice is always between two equally matched forces, equal in weight according to each individual’s spiritual level. Both sides stand before him in genuine equilibrium, and nevertheless, he can decide between them. That is the very definition of the word bechirah—that a person chooses one side.

Yet once we grant that the doubt is real, how can a koach ha’hachra’ah exist between two genuinely balanced forces? One pulls in this direction, the other pulls in that direction, and the gravitational pull of both is identical. From where does the power arise to tip the scale toward one side over the other?

It is insufficient to argue that upon reflection, the intellect (seichel) compels one side—for if so, once again, it is not bechirah. That is the precise locus of the battle! The battle occurs specifically when seichel pulls in one direction while the inclination of the heart—the powerful ratzon—pulls in the opposite direction, even while knowing full well what seichel dictates. Thus, one stands suspended between two equally matched forces. From where, then, can one generate the power to decide?

A Katan Lives Fragmented; a Gadol Lives Within a Mahalach

The depth of the matter is this: any human being, as he stands naturally, can be viewed as a mere collection of desires, drives, and impulses—a chaotic jumble of competing forces pulling in every direction. The ordinary person we encounter is generally not one unified person. The shifts from one desire to another, from one mood to another, happen within moments; a person can undergo five, seven, or even ten radical swings within a single hour, oscillating from one extreme to the other. Within minutes, he can crave something and then be repulsed by that very same thing.

However, the possibility exists for a person to forge himself into one unified human being—so that from the sole of his foot to the crown of his head, he constitutes one cohesive tzuras Adam (human form), one unified entity, rather than a patchwork of disparate drives.

This is the precise distinction in Lashon HaKodesh between katan (small) and gadol (great):

  • The word katan in Lashon HaKodesh denotes something katu’a (severed/fragmented)—piece after piece after piece, with no continuous trajectory (mahalach).

  • Conversely, the word gadol shares its root with gadah (the bank of a river)—something continuous and sustained. Just as a river flows continuously along its bank, that which possesses unbroken continuity is termed gadol, whereas that which is fragmented—one thing this moment, something else the next moment, and something entirely new a moment later—is termed katan.

This defines a person who is truly gadol: he lives his life within a cohesive mahalach—an unbroken continuum. He is not a brand-new person every passing second.

One Cannot Defeat a Force Using Raw Force Alone

Now, when the struggle is framed strictly as force against force, the forces are evenly matched; there is no isolated drive capable of overpowering its counterpart. However, when a person integrates all his faculties and forges himself into one unified human being—in that very act, whereby the choosing individual makes himself into an Adam, there lies the power of bechirah.

When a person gathers and synthesizes all his faculties into one cohesive tzuras Adam—and specifically when he shapes himself into the authentic, requisite form of Adam as it is meant to be—within that tzuras Adam, he has already chosen the good.

A person cannot overpower a drive when the counter-force at his disposal cannot outweigh it. Where could he summon the strength to overcome an opposing pull when dealing purely with clashing impulses? Naturally, when two conflicting pulls tug in opposite directions, he will follow whichever exerts the stronger, more immediate gravity. Purely on the plane of raw force, man lacks the strength to defeat an urge pulling him toward evil. True, everything he knows, reasoned, and resolved is correct—yet the sheer magnetic pull of the desire is powerful enough that he cannot withstand it head-on. From where, then, does he draw the strength to stand firm against a force he cannot match on its own terms?

Choosing Good Means Refusing to Contradict Tzuras Adam

The answer is that it operates not through raw counter-force, but through a fundamentally different form—a different anchoring of one's essential tzuras Adam. When a person establishes himself as a whole, coherent Adam—one who lives in unbroken continuity, who is the same unified person yesterday, today, and tomorrow—within that tzuras Adam, he can withstand those overwhelming pulls. Why? Because that action is fundamentally incompatible with the trajectory of his tzuras Adam. Once a person identifies wholly with the authentic, proper form of Adam, and that becomes his very identity, he has already chosen good. Here lies the true choice of good.

It is now clear: man does not manufacture the power to choose good out of his arsenal of raw drives. That is precisely his nisayon (test), his nekudas ha’bechirah (point of choice), and the exact arena where raw willpower fails. Pitting drive against drive will not work. Rather, what he can bring to bear against the temptation is the recognition that it violates his very tzuras Adam—and once anchored there, the test diminishes dramatically.

Indeed, when an inclination pulls powerfully yet contradicts the essence of tzuras Adam, and a person feels he lacks the raw strength to overpower it—that is the exact nekudas ha’bechirah, the purpose for which man was created. As the Mesillas Yesharim writes in Chapter 1: "We learn that the essence of man's existence in this world is solely to fulfill mitzvos, to serve Hashem, and to withstand tests." That is the telos of human creation.

Every Failure Lowers the Nekudas HaBechirah

Consequently, whenever a person fails at his nekudas ha’bechirah, two things occur: first, he fails in his primary mandate as a human being—not for this was he created; it is a fracture in his very tzuras Adam. Second, his subsequent test will occur on a far lower, more severe plane. His nekudas ha’bechirah has dropped; he has lost a section of the protective wall—that cohesive form with which man withstands every test.

In the moment of nisayon, the Creator commands us: "U’vacharta bachayim lema’an tichyeh" (Devarim 30:19). We are commanded to choose life. And from where do we draw the strength when, as established, the choice is genuine and the two opposing forces are balanced in equal measure? The power to withstand it is tzuras Adam.

The Tzuras Adam Shattered in the Sin Was Restored in Yaakov

Here we must understand: ever since Adam HaRishon sinned, tzuras Adam was shattered. It disintegrated into fragments once a foreign force entered inside man. From that point onward, a fractured system of competing forces and desires took over tzuras Adam; man ceased to be Adam.

Tzuras Adam returned to the world with Klal Yisrael, as it is stated in Yechezkel (34:31): "V’aten tzoni tzon mar’isi, Adam atem"—You are called Adam. And it returned through that Master of the Flock, of whom Chazal say (Bereishis Rabbah 73:11) that he possessed six hundred thousand (shishim ribo) sheep. We are called tzon kodashim; throughout Torah Shebichsav, Klal Yisrael is called tzon, as in "Nachisa k’tzon amecha b’yad Moshe v’Aharon" (Tehillim 77:21).

The Gemara in Yevamos (61a) expounds on "Adam atem": "אתם קרויין אדם"—You are called Adam. After tzuras Adam had been ruined and ceased to exist, the one who restored tzuras Adam to its rightful place was Yaakov Avinu, concerning whom the Gemara in Bava Metzia (84a) states: "Shufrei d’Yaakov Avinu mei’ein shufrei d’Adam HaRishon"—the beauty of Yaakov Avinu was akin to the beauty of Adam HaRishon before the sin, exactly as he emerged from the hands of the Creator.

"V’hinei malachei Elokim olim v’yordim bo" (Bereishis 28:12). Regarding those angels ascending and descending, Chazal teach (cited in part by Rashi) that they descended and gazed upon Yaakov’s image below, and ascended and gazed upon that exact same image engraved upon the Kisei HaKavod above. Chazal even note that "olim v’yordim bo" means on Yaakov himself. Yaakov’s form exists below and above in identical measure—from the highest celestial pinnacle down to the lowest earthly point, it is the exact same Adam. That is what is called an ish tam—completely whole, one unified person.

The Attributes of Avraham and Yitzchak Compared to Yaakov

Now, regarding Avraham and Yitzchak, the Gemara states that zuhama had not yet ceased from them—were it not explicitly written, one could never utter such a thing, yet such is the Gemara’s wording: "Ad sheloshah doros lo paskah zuhama mei’avoseinu." This teaches us that the root cause of Yishmael’s emergence lay in Avraham, and the root cause of Eisav’s emergence lay in Yitzchak. There was a trace of unintegrated residue within our forefathers themselves, which manifested externally in Avraham through Yishmael and in Yitzchak through Eisav.

What does this mean according to our limited grasp? The attributes of Avraham and Yitzchak were colossal spiritual forces, yet they were specific, singular attributes. Chessed is one attribute among the full spectrum of attributes comprising tzuras Adam. Certainly, it was the dominant attribute, overpowering all other tendencies—this was Avraham Avinu, the paradigm of Chessed, "Titein emes l’Yaakov, chessed l’Avraham" (Michah 7:20), mirroring the Creator’s own Chessed. Nevertheless, Chessed is a single, specific koach. And any isolated koach can always be channeled in one direction or inverted toward its opposite; the very same force can operate constructively or destructively. The exact same applies to Yitzchak’s attribute of Gevurah.

Middas Ha’Emes: One Continuous Mahalach Where Everything Aligns

"Titein emes l’Yaakov, chessed l’Avraham." That attribute called Emes is the middah that spans from the very first, highest point down to the final endpoint in one unbroken mahalach. This is the meaning of the word אמת, as the Gemara in Shabbos (104a) explains: "Emes merachaka mileih"—and Rashi explains that the letters of אמ"ת stand at the beginning of the Alef-Beis (א), the exact middle (מ), and the very end (ת)—reisha d’asvan, metzi’asa d’asvan, v’seifa d’asvan: from beginning to end by way of the center.

When a reality extends from its primordial root all the way to its final actualization in complete harmony, that is called Emes. "She’kulam mas’imos" (Shir HaShirim 4:2)—all aligned in perfect correspondence: every branch aligns with the root, and every subsequent development aligns seamlessly with what preceded it. That was Yaakov Avinu. The sole distinction between our forefathers from whom zuhama had not ceased and Yaakov Avinu from whom zuhama ceased lies in this exact point.

The Forces of the Avos Are Manifestations of Hashem’s Attributes

Avraham Avinu and Yitzchak Avinu channeled titanic spiritual forces—Avraham’s Chessed and Yitzchak’s Gevurah—of such awesome intensity that they parallel Hashem’s own attributes: "Elokei Avraham, Elokei Yitzchak."

Indeed, we find that Yaakov took an oath, as it says: "Vayishava Yaakov b’Pachad aviv Yitzchak" (Bereishis 31:53). Now, it is strictly forbidden to swear by "fear" or by any created entity unless that Pachad is one of the attributes of the Borei Olam—making it an oath by a Divine appellation (kinui). Under any other circumstance, swearing by something other than Hashem is strictly prohibited; as the Rambam writes (Sefer HaMitzvos, Mitzvas Aseh 7), anyone who swears by any entity, treating that entity as possessing intrinsic reality ("v’hu sover ki ladavar hahu amitus b’atzmuso"), violates the positive command of "U’vishmo tishavei’a" (Devarim 6:13). Thus, when Yaakov swore by "Pachad aviv Yitzchak," he was swearing by one of Hashem’s own manifestations.

The Power of a Single Attribute vs. the Complete Synthesis

So it was with Chessed l’Avraham and Pachad Yitzchak—both were immense, singular kochos. However, when we speak of the lofty level that integrates and synthesizes all forces into one cohesive mahalach, into one unified tzuras Adam, every single force must participate in exact proportion. No single force may protrude disproportionately beyond the whole. The moment one force protrudes outside the balanced system, that very protrusion can generate an equal protrusion in the opposite direction.

That very same Chessed of Avraham—just as it brought into the world the Chessed of Creation itself ("b’hibar’am — b’Avraham"), so too could an unintegrated Chessed manifest in the world as "chessed hu" in the context of illicit unions (Vayikra 20:17), which Rashi translates via Aramaic as cherpah (disgrace/abomination). That exact same middah, when detached from the rest of the attributes rather than unified into one cohesive, whole mahalach, can invert.

A truly whole entity must take into account and balance the entire system. This is what the Borei Olam intended when He created Adam; this is what is demanded of man. Man must embody that precise form which the Creator sculpted.

All of Creation Unites Around the Revelation of Tzuras Adam

When a human being shapes himself into this complete tzuras Adam, living within a clear mahalach aligned with the Creator’s blueprint, all of Creation reaches its purpose through him. This is the tzuras Adam that Hashem intended. And at that moment, Creation itself gathers all its scattered details and forces and fuses into one. That is the secret of "Vayikach mei’avnei hamakom vayasem m’ra’ashosav."

Yaakov Avinu walks along the road, and his journey is to construct that tzuras Adam of "atem keruyin Adam." All those who have not attained this form—who remain mere offshoots of the tzuras Adam shattered in Adam HaRishon’s sin—are not called Adam; whereas all who are products of the rectification (tikkun) of that shattering are called Adam.

Yaakov is the complete Adam, whose image is engraved upon the Kisei HaKavod. When such a tzuras Adam appears in the world, all the forces of Creation instinctively converge and unite around him, because Creation itself was brought into existence solely to arrive at this tzuras Adam. The entire universe was created for Adam; when Creation beholds the very Adam for whom it was made, the entire cosmos unites with him.

Both Manifestations Converge to Reveal Beis Elokim

In these twin manifestations was this form revealed: in the angels ascending and descending the ladder to behold Yaakov’s tzuras Adam, and in the fusion of the stones. Each stone represents an independent force capable of serving as the foundation for a separate structure; yet all these stones merged into one single stone—the Even HaShesiyah, the cornerstone of all reality. The entire universe was created to connect, synthesize, and become one unified chorus proclaiming the single truth Creation was meant to declare: "Kol mah she’bara Hakadosh Baruch Hu b’olamo lo bara’o ela lichvodo" (Avos 6:12). And when does Creation declare this? When that intended tzuras Adam is revealed in the world. Both revelations together proclaim that this place is Beis Elokim.

All Forces in the World Are Rooted in Tziyon — Beis Elokim

Chazal teach on the pasuk "Mi’Tziyon michlal yofi Elokim hofi’a" (Tehillim 50:2) that Tziyon is the primary foundation (mashtiso) of the world (Tanchuma, Kedoshim 10), meaning that from Tziyon emanate the life-forces operating throughout the entire globe. Arteries and conduits (gidim) extend from Tziyon to every corner of the earth, and everything that sprouts and grows from the soil draws its vitality from Tziyon.

Thus Rashi cites Chazal on Koheles (2:5), "V’natati bahem eitz kol peri":

"Shlomo HaMelech, through his wisdom, recognized the subterranean arteries of the earth—which artery led to Kush, and he planted pepper there; which led to the land of carobs, and he planted carobs there—for all the arteries of the lands converge in Tziyon, from which the world was founded."

Shlomo HaMelech knew which artery nourished every land and planted each region’s unique flora right over its corresponding artery in Yerushalayim. This was one expression of Shlomo’s chochmah. The definition of chochmah is knowing the ultimate root (shoresh) of every phenomenon in Creation. Because Shlomo was wiser than all men, he grasped the true root of every force in the world and how each emerges from its source. Therefore, Shlomo built the Beis HaMikdash—the locus from which shefa flows to the entire universe. Beis Elokim is the place where the root of all forces is revealed, gathering and fusing them into one unified reality.

Through the Revelation of Yaakov’s Tzuras Adam, Beis Elokim Was Revealed

When Yaakov Avinu’s tzuras Adam—the ultimate aim of Creation—was revealed, it became manifest that all of Creation converges around that tzuras Adam. This was revealed through the stone Yaakov placed beneath his head, which became Beis Elokim, because this site holds within it all roots together as one unified form.

All of Creation was brought into being through the Divine Name Elokim. As it were, Elokim has a "home"—a locus from which He goes forth to act, as in "Yeitzei adam l’fa’alo v’la’avodaso adei arev" (Tehillim 104:23), going out from his house and returning to his house. Beis Elokim is the "House" from which all the forces of Creation—all thirty-two mentions of Elokim in Ma’aseh Bereishis—emanate. When Yaakov’s tzuras Adam was revealed, this reality became manifest right there, establishing that this place is Beis Elokim.

Yaakov, Having Synthesized All Forces, Could Roll Away the Stone

Yaakov continues on his journey: "Vayisa Yaakov raglav vayelech artzah bnei kedem. Vayar v’hinei be’er basadeh... v’ha’even gedolah al pi habe’er" (Bereishis 29:1–2). Normally, all the flocks and all the shepherds had to gather together to roll the massive stone off the mouth of the well: "V’ne’esfu shamah kol ha’adarim v’galalu es ha’even."

Yet the Torah teaches us that Yaakov Avinu performed this feat single-handedly: "Vayigash Yaakov vayagel es ha’even mei’al pi habe’er" (ibid., 29:10). Rashi comments: "להודיעך שכוחו גדול"—to inform you that his strength was immense. What is the Torah telling us with "l’hodi’acha she’kocho gadol"? Is it merely reporting that Yaakov was a physical strongman? What are we meant to learn from this?

The meaning is that here too, everything converged. What all the shepherds could only accomplish collectively existed within Yaakov Avinu alone. Yaakov had gathered the entirety of tzuras Adam into one cohesive unity; and when everything is gathered into one, all of Creation responds to him. When a person does not sleep for fourteen years—sleeping only a single night in fourteen years and even regretting that—he attains such spiritual potency that he can roll away that boulder as effortlessly as pulling a cork from a bottle. That is what "l’lamedcha she’kocho gadol" comes to teach us!

In the piyut of Tefillas Geshem, we recite: "Zechor ta’an maklo v’avar Yarden mayim, yichud lev v’gal even mei’al pi be’er mayim." Yaakov’s feat of rolling the stone off the well was achieved specifically through "yichud lev"—he unified his heart! The heart is the wellspring of life ("ki mimenu totza’os chaim", Mishlei 4:23). Yaakov unified his heart—he integrated all his faculties together, never allowing any single drive to splinter off and act independently. Because every force within him was bound together in total synthesis, Yaakov could roll away the stone alone. Normally, rolling the stone required "v’ne’esfu shamah kol ha’adarim"—all the shepherds uniting—yet Yaakov contained all of them within himself.

The Heap of Stones Testifies to the Divide Between Yaakov and Lavan

So it runs from the start of the parashah to its very end. At the conclusion of the parashah, the Torah states: "Liktu avanim vaya’asu gal... vayikra lo Yaakov Gal-Ed" (Bereishis 31:46–47). This mound serves as an eternal witness—"Eid hagal hazeh v’eidah hamatzeivah" (ibid., 31:52)—testifying that there is no point of connection whatsoever between Yaakov and Lavan [so much so that without this boundary mound, some trace of connection between Yaakov and Lavan could still have remained].

In the Haggadah shel Pesach, we declare: "She’Paroh lo gazar ela al hazechorim, v’Lavan bikeish la’akor es hakol"—Pharaoh decreed only against the males, whereas Lavan sought to uproot everything! Where do we see that Lavan sought to uproot everything—even more thoroughly than Pharaoh—and how?

The Rishonim explain that this occurred in one single statement, when Lavan declared: "Habanos benosai v’habanim banai v’hatzon tzoni v’chol asher atah ro’eh li hu" (ibid., 31:43). That is uprooting everything from its very root! Because the moment Lavan claims to be the root of everything, it means everything is severed from its true spiritual root. All of Klal Yisrael, everything Yaakov Avinu built—if any aspect of it is attributed to Lavan, that constitutes uprooting the entire edifice down to its foundation.

These are the final stones in this parashah—the stones that erected the partition between the tzuras Adam of "atem keruyin Adam" and the form of those who are not called Adam: "Liktu avanim vaya’asu gal... eid hagal hazeh v’eidah hamatzeivah." Whoever belongs to this belongs to the attribute of "Emes l’Yaakov." Until Yaakov Avinu’s tzuras Adam was revealed, we did not yet possess Emes.

Eisav vs. Yaakov: "Yesh Li Rav" vs. "Yesh Li Kol"

We must understand: the Geulah for which we yearn speedily in our days will culminate in: "V’hayah Hashem l’Melech al kol ha’aretz, bayom hahu yihyeh Hashem Echad u’Shemo Echad" (Zecharyah 14:9)—a verse we recite multiple times every single day in tefillah.

And who rises up to wage war against this? Gog and Magog, who march forth to battle against Hashem and His Mashiach. Here we must recognize that this titanic, fateful conflict—explicitly foretold in the Torah and the Nevi’im—revolves specifically and entirely around this exact point.

We strive and yearn to bring the entire world to Echad—to unite and synthesize all of creation into one cohesive reality: "Bayom hahu yihyeh Hashem Echad u’Shemo Echad." Conversely, the entire objective of Gog and Magog is to wage war against this exact unification. They fight because they champion a world of ribbui (fragmented multiplicity) rather than a world of Echad [as the Gra notes, Gog u’Magog equals seventy in gematria]. Their very essence is the antithesis of Echad; unity contradicts their existence. As Yechezkel (39:11) states: "V’kar’u lah Gei Hamon Gog"—Gog arrives as a hamon (a fragmented multitude), fighting for multiplicity against Melech HaMashiach, whose entire mission is to bring the world to "Bayom hahu yihyeh Hashem Echad u’Shemo Echad."

The true, innermost battle—the struggle upon which everything hinges—is between the complete tzuras Adam and their fragmented multiplicity: the battle between Yaakov and Eisav. As Rashi writes (Bereishis 46:26):

"Eisav had six souls, yet Scripture refers to them as 'nafshos beiso' in the plural... Yaakov had seventy souls, yet Scripture refers to them as 'nefesh' in the singular."

Similarly, in next week’s parashah, Parashas Vayishlach, Eisav declares: "יֶשׁ לִי רָב אָחִי"—"I have plenty (rav), my brother" (Bereishis 33:9)—while Yaakov responds: "כִּי חַנַּנִי אֱלֹקִים וְכִי יֶשׁ לִי כֹל"—"G-d has favored me, and I have everything (kol)" (ibid., 33:11). One boasts of rav (mere accumulation and multiplicity), while the other boasts of kol (integrated wholeness).

For Eisav, the ultimate ideal is simply more—accumulating more and more disconnected things. Whereas regarding Yaakov Avinu—Klal Yisrael—the Torah states: "Lo mei’rubchem chashak Hashem bachem ki atem hame’at mikol ha’amim" (Devarim 7:7). We seek kol; we seek one unified form—a reality in which every force is integrated and synthesized into one complete, all-encompassing whole.

Here lies the great divide. Anyone who looks out at the modern world today sees the culture of ribbui—a civilization hurtling toward endless multiplicity, dedicated solely to adding more and more disconnected sensations, chasing novelty and distractions. To that mindset, unifying everything into Echad appears unbearably boring; far more stimulating is having this, and that, and another thing—endless pizur (scattering). They aren't even embarrassed to call their culture bidur (entertainment)—whose root in Aramaic literally means scattering (pizur)! The greater the fragmentation, the more celebrated the culture.

If we wish to attain the exact opposite, we must recognize that this mindset is the very force waging war against us, seeking to uproot us from our source, fighting against Hashem and His Mashiach. Anyone who embraces that fragmentation enlists in the armies marching against Hashem and His Mashiach.

This is the central message of our parashah for us. May Hashem help us integrate ourselves into that unified tzuras Adam—the form that will ultimately triumph and bring the entire world to its tikkun. And let us remember: if we do not bind ourselves to this tzuras Adam, if we are not for it, then chas v’shalom we align ourselves with those who battle against us.

With Hashem’s help, speedily in our days, may we merit the fulfillment of: "V’hayah Hashem l’Melech al kol ha’aretz, bayom hahu yihyeh Hashem Echad u’Shemo Echad."