The kashya is a bomb and although the author doesn't say so explicitly [he just quotes the source without mentioning names so I added it in when I copied it] - the kashya is from Mori Vi-rabbi Shlita. The terutz is quite clever but I don't know if it is emes. I gave a copy of the article to Mori Vi-rabi Slita and I hope he tells me what he thinks....
The author sent me the article today and asked me what I think. I have to think....:-).