Wednesday, November 23, 2016

Can We Disqualify The Co-witness Of An Eid Zomeim?

לזכות ידיד נפשי ר' שמואל צבי בן ר' דוד עקיבא וכל בני ביתו!

What is the din of a co-witness of a witness became an עד זומם. One Acharon thought that it was pashut that he is disqualified because he testified that they were together and he was proven to be a liar [pants on ...]. 

How does this  Image result for square image 

square with the halacha that if one person testifies about something and says that Ploni was with him and Ploni denies it he is not disqualified because people don't always notice carefully who was with them?