Wednesday, October 14, 2026

Hilchos Melachim

A religious member of Knesset spoke at a conference and was trying to demonstrate how democratic Judaism is. He said that if the Sanhedrin isn't happy with a king they can dethrone him. That is a big chiddush. The Rambam says that a king is a king for life. Others hold that under certain circumstances a king can be removed [and not necessarily by the Sanhedrin. See an article on this in the sefer עדרו ירעה pages 151-191].

He also said that the people decide who is going to be king. That is not accurate. The king is installed by the Sanhedrin and a Navi  [הלכות מלכים א-ג]. 

He also said that in the absence of a king the Sanhedrin acts as king. I don't know where that came from. 

For more information there are hundreds of shiurim on line in Hilchos Melachim [which this writer may or may not have something to do with]. A worthwhile listen.