Rabbi Moshe Gorelick
European Jews are facing hard times, not only due to the rise in anti-Semitic violence, but also because of interference by local educational boards in the curricula of Jewish day schools, chadarim, high schools, and yeshivos for high-school-age boys. Local askanim and community rabbanim are stumped in their fight against demands that Jewish schools give equal time to heretical, anti-creationist teachings. In the UK, where there is a tangible threat of a newly anti-Semitic Labour Party taking over the reins of government, a large percentage of Jews feel that the ground is burning under their feet and are considering emigration.
But among those who are scouting out greener pastures, only a small number are contemplating aliyah. The question is, why? It is understood that those Jews who live in the Diaspora have many reasons for staying where they are, but today, with the year 2019 on the horizon, as many Jews prepare to pull up their stakes and take their old wandering staffs out of storage, why isn’t Eretz Yisrael their first option? Israel today is a highly developed country and able to happily absorb many chareidi immigrants. Every one of them adds another bit of kedushah to the State of Israel simply by living here, and lends the strength of numbers to the struggle for the primacy of Torah in Jewish life. If they’re looking for a comfortable life, Israel today has plenty to offer in terms of convenience and creature comforts. If it’s a good school system they want, a wide range of excellent educational options for chareidi students can be found here. And despite all the buzz about the draft and threats to the yeshivah world, the fact is that chareidi education continues to flourish and grow.
Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, the venerated rav of the Old Yishuv, framed the situation quite accurately in his time, before the founding of the state. “Where,” he asked sadly, “are the frum olim? Why aren’t they coming to Eretz Yisrael?” He went on to say, “In our Mussaf prayers, we say, ‘Because of our sins we were exiled from our Land, and we have wandered far from our soil.’ ” These are two different matters, he explained. “Because of our sins we were exiled” — that is one matter. “And we have wandered far from our soil” — that is another matter. In the countries of our exile, we have become distant from our soil. Our mentality and feelings have changed, and we no longer feel attached to the soil of Eretz Yisrael. So said the staunchly anti-Zionist but passionately pro-Eretz Yisrael gadol hador in the 1930s, when aliyah was incomparably more difficult than it is today. And now that conditions are so vastly improved, must we still remain so far from our soil?
(Originally featured in Mishpacha, Issue 740)
