B'chasdei Hashem, over the past almost 20 years, Beis Mevakesh Lev has produced over 13,300 audio shiurim and over 31,000 written posts, unmatched by any one-person website - all completely free of charge. There are no paywalls or anything else. Now we are turning to you for help so we can continue - any amount will help. Even 99 cents! Thank you to my sweetest and most beloved friends!!!:-)!!
alchehrm@gmail.com
Introduction: The Question of Redundancy
The discourse opens by analyzing the description of Matan Torah. We are told that Moshe Rabbeinu brought down the Luchos (Tablets) containing Shmiras Shabbos (Shabbos observance), “just as it is written in Your Torah.” The speaker challenges this seemingly redundant phrasing: If Shabbos is already recorded in the Torah scroll, why is it necessary to specify that it was also inscribed on the stone Tablets?
1. The Anthropological Hierarchy: Man as Microcosm
The speaker explains that the world consists of four levels: Domem (Inanimate), Tzomeach (Vegetative), Chai (Animal), and Medaber (Speaker/Man). Man is designed to be the synthesis of all creation.
Physiological Elevation: When Man eats plants or animals, he elevates these lower life forms internally, integrating them into his flesh and blood and raising them to the level of intellect.
The Problem of the Inanimate: How does Man encompass the Domem—the rocks and stones—which he does not consume?
The Resolution of Adornment: The answer lies in the metaphor of the Kallah (Bride). A human reaches completion through external adornment with jewelry (stones and precious metals). By wearing the “stone,” Man elevates the lowest level of creation, demonstrating that his dominion extends even to the lifeless earth.
2. The Nimshal: The Scholar and the Text
This physical hierarchy maps onto the spiritual structure of a Talmid Chochom (Torah Scholar).
Intellect vs. Letters: A scholar’s primary engagement is usually with Torah Shebaal Peh—the “living” intellect and understanding of the Law. However, the Midrash states a scholar must also be adorned with the “24 Books of Tanach.”
The “Stone” of Torah: Why is Scripture (Tanach) compared to jewelry? Because reading Written Scripture (Torah Shebiksav) is unique: one fulfills the Mitzvah even without understanding the meaning. The holiness lies in the mere Osios (letters).
The Parallel: Just as the inanimate stone completes the human body via jewelry, the “inanimate” letters of Scripture—which require no active intellect to be holy—are the adornments that complete the spiritual stature of the scholar. Without fluency in the simple text, the scholar is incomplete.
3. The Halachic Status of the Luchos (Written vs. Oral)
This framework explains the specific nature of the Luchos. They represent the descent of Torah into Domem (physical stone).
The Rule: Halacha typically dictates a strict separation between Written and Oral Torah (”Things written down you are not permitted to recite by heart”). This rule applies to Torah given for the purpose of Limmud (learning/study).
The Exception: The Luchos, however, were not given primarily as a text for public study, but as a physical object (Cheftza) to be stored in the Holy Ark. If what was on the luchos was not also in the Torah there would be no prohibition of saying it by heart.
The Implication: Because the Luchos are defined as a given object rather than a study text, the standard Halachic prohibition against reciting Written Torah by heart does not apply to them. On the Luchos, the distinction between Written and Oral collapses; the text holds a unique status where it is simultaneously Written yet accessible as Oral. This mirrors how the “stone” becomes fully integrated into the identity of the Man/Scholar [because he represents this duality of learning-without-understanding-stone and learning-with-da’as-Talmid-Chochom].
4. The Specificity of Shabbos
Finally, the speaker addresses why Shabbos specifically had to be highlighted on these stones.
Fixed Holiness (Kvia v’Kayma): Unlike Festivals, which require human Courts to sanctify the time, Shabbos is holy from the creation of the world, independent of human input. It is “fixed,” much like a stone is fixed and static.
The Ultimate Integration: Writing Shabbos (a holiness that requires no human processing) on the Luchos (inanimate stone) signifies the ultimate purpose of Creation: The permeation of Holiness into the static, inanimate reality (Olam Ha’Asiyah).
Conclusion
The redundant mention of Shabbos on the Tablets teaches us that the Torah is not merely an intellectual pursuit. Just as Man is incomplete without elevating the “stone” via jewelry, and the Scholar is incomplete without the simple “letters” of Scripture, the revelation at Sinai was only complete when the holiness of Shabbos—a holiness that exists objectively and without human input—was etched into the physical substance of the world.
