Be a Partner in the Pulse of Beis Mevakesh Lev - For almost 20 years, B’chasdei Hashem, this space has been a home for seekers—a place where Torah is accessible to everyone, everywhere, without a paywall. We’ve shared over thousands and thousands of pages of learning together. But to keep the lights on and ensure this library remains free and growing for the next generation of Mevakshei Lev, I need your partnership.
Your contribution isn't just a donation; it's the fuel that keeps these shiurim reaching hearts across the globe. Whether it’s the cost of a coffee or a monthly sponsorship, you are making this Torah possible.
[Donate via PayPal/Zelle: alchehrm@gmail.com] Thank you to my beloved friends for standing with me.
I. Introduction: The Centrality of the Auditory Faculty
The lecture begins by examining the physiological and spiritual uniqueness of the ear. While the lecturer notes the anatomical perfection of the ear for maximizing sound and maintaining balance, the primary focus is the theological question: Why is the faculty of hearing the gateway to Jewish faith?
The acceptance of the "Yoke of Heaven" is performed via the declaration of Shema Yisrael ("Hear, O Israel"). Furthermore, the lecture juxtaposes this with the laws of the Eved Ivri (Hebrew slave) found in Parshas Mishpatim. When a slave refuses his mandated freedom after six years, declaring love for his master and refusing to leave, the Torah commands that his ear be pierced against a doorpost (Exodus 21:6). The lecture aims to synthesize these two concepts to define the essence of a Jew's relationship with the Divine.
II. The Perspective of the Pachad Yitzchak: The Ear as the Organ of Servitude
Drawing upon the Pachad Yitzchak (Rav Yitzchak Hutner), the lecture constructs a legal and metaphysical argument regarding the nature of the ear.
The Legal Status of the Deaf (Cheireish): In Talmudic tort law, blinding a person requires monetary compensation for the value of the eye. However, deafening a person requires compensation for the entire value of the person, effectively treating the deafened individual as if they were dead.
Total Receptivity: Rav Hutner explains this distinction by analyzing the sensory organs. The mouth, hands, and even the eyes have active, expressive components (output). The ear, however, is unique; it is the only organ that is purely receptive (kli kibul). It takes in but does not put out.
Definition of Slavery: True servitude is defined by total subordination and receptivity to the will of the master. Because the ear is the physiological embodiment of absolute receptivity, it is the primary organ of Avdus (slavery).
The Blemish of the Refusing Slave: The Hebrew slave who rejects freedom has failed in his capacity to "listen." At Sinai, the ear heard that the Children of Israel are servants to God alone, not servants to other humans. By choosing a human master, the slave demonstrates a spiritual deafness. Therefore, the ear—the organ responsible for receiving the Divine command and the symbol of servitude—must be pierced (blemished) to reflect the slave’s damaged spiritual faculty.
III. The Perspective of the Sfas Emes: Na’aseh V’Nishma and the Rejection of Stagnation
The lecture transitions to the commentary of the Sfas Emes (The Gerer Rebbe), grappling with a contradiction: The slave’s sin appears to be one of action (choosing to stay), yet the punishment is directed at the hearing.
Hearing as the Root of Action: Citing the Chiddushei Harim, the lecture establishes that a failure in action is symptomatic of a failure in hearing. If one truly "heard" (internalized) the command, the action would inevitably follow.
The "Free Fish" and the Yoke of Heaven: The lecture utilizes the Zohar’s interpretation of the Israelites’ complaint in the desert about remembering the fish they ate in Egypt "for free" (chinam). The Zohar interprets chinam not as monetary freedom, but as "free from the Mitzvos." The desire for Egypt was a desire to be free from the burden of the Yoke of Heaven.
The Human Master vs. The Divine Master: Serving a human master is finite; the demands are limited to the workday. Serving God is infinite and constant. The slave who refuses freedom is essentially saying, "I prefer the limited, easier yoke of a human to the infinite, all-encompassing yoke of God."
The Cycle of Doing and Hearing: The Jewish ideal is Na’aseh V’Nishma ("We will do and we will hear"). This is interpreted not as a one-time event, but as a perpetual cycle. A servant of God performs the current will (Na’aseh) and immediately seeks to "hear" (Nishma) what more can be done. It represents a constant drive for spiritual growth and deeper servitude.
The Stagnation of the Slave: The slave who says "I love my master, I will not go free" is rejecting the Nishma—the desire to hear more and grow further. He is content with his current level of service. By rejecting the dynamic, infinite growth of Divine service, he blemishes his faculty of Nishma. Consequently, his ear is pierced to symbolize his inability to truly hear and accept the infinite command of God.
IV. Conclusion: True Freedom through Total Servitude
The lecture concludes by redefining the concepts of freedom and slavery.
The Paradox of Freedom: Total autonomy is often an illusion or a path to spiritual emptiness. True freedom (Cheirus) is found only in the total acceptance of the Yoke of Heaven.
Torah Study as Freedom: Learning Torah is the mechanism by which one engages in Nishma—constantly listening to the Divine will. This intellectual and spiritual submission to God liberates the individual from the arbitrary and finite constraints of the physical world and human masters.
In summary, the ear is pierced because it is the vessel of reception. A Jew is designed to receive the infinite word of God; when one voluntarily substitutes that for the finite word of a man, they have corrupted the very purpose of their existence as a "listener" (Shema) to the Divine.
